The Leadership Crisis We're Not Talking About in Schools

When people talk about a “leadership crisis” in schools, the conversation usually goes in a pretty familiar direction. Students are not motivated enough, they are not accountable enough, or they are simply not stepping up the way they used to. I hear that a lot from educators, and I understand where it comes from, but after spending years speaking in schools and working with over 100,000 students, I do not think that is actually what is happening.

From what I have seen, the issue is not that students lack leadership potential. It is that most students are not consistently given real opportunities to practice leadership in everyday situations. When you look at it through that lens, what we often label as a leadership problem starts to look more like a practice problem.

For a long time, leadership in schools has been tied to titles. Student council, team captains, club presidents, honor societies. Those roles absolutely matter and they give students valuable experiences, but they also only represent a very small portion of the student population. The challenge is that leadership was never meant to belong only to a group of students with titles. It was always something broader than that.

Leadership shows up in much smaller moments that often go unnoticed. It is introducing yourself to someone you do not know. It is speaking up when you have an idea in class. It is choosing to include someone who is sitting alone. It is taking responsibility when something does not go your way. It is communication, connection, and influence in everyday life, not just in formal positions.

When I go into schools, one of the things I notice right away is how quickly students respond when they are actually given a chance to interact with each other in a more intentional way. If I ask students to turn to someone they do not know and start a conversation, there is usually hesitation at first. Not because they do not care and not because they are not capable, but because many of them have not had enough practice doing it.

That makes a lot of sense when you think about how communication has evolved for this generation. Students are communicating constantly, but a large portion of that communication happens through screens. Texts, group chats, social media, comments, messages. They are connected all day long, but that does not always translate into confidence in face-to-face communication or real-time conversation.

So when we put them in situations that require that kind of interaction, whether it is introducing themselves, speaking in front of others, or leading a group discussion, it can feel unfamiliar. Again, not because they are lacking ability, but because they are lacking experience.

That is where I think schools have a real opportunity right now. If leadership is ultimately about communication, confidence, and connection, then it cannot just be something reserved for a small group of students in specific roles. It has to be something that every student is exposed to and given space to develop over time.

Because regardless of what path a student takes after high school, they are going to need those skills. They will need to communicate in interviews, collaborate on teams, build relationships in new environments, and advocate for themselves in situations that matter. Those are all leadership moments, even if they do not come with a title attached to them.

What I have also found is that students are far more capable than we sometimes assume. When they are placed in environments where they are encouraged to communicate, connect, and step slightly outside their comfort zone, most of them rise to it quickly. The hesitation is usually temporary. Once they experience success in those moments, confidence builds fast.

That is why I do not think the leadership issue in schools is really about motivation. It is about opportunity. And when schools start intentionally creating more of those opportunities, even in small and consistent ways, the culture inside the building starts to shift.

You begin to see students interacting differently. You see more confidence in classrooms. You see more willingness to participate. You see more awareness of how they treat each other in hallways and shared spaces. Leadership starts to show up in more places, not just in selected programs or selected students.

At the end of the day, I do not think the goal is to create more “leaders” in the traditional sense. I think the goal is to help students recognize that they already have the ability to lead in their own way, starting right where they are.

At Vitt Factor, I do not approach leadership as a concept that students simply learn about. I approach it as something they need space to actually practice.

Through our assemblies and workshops, we focus on helping students build communication, confidence, and leadership skills that translate into real situations they will face in school and beyond. We also have a Future Leaders Team, where students are given ongoing opportunities to practice what they are learning in real time. They work on speaking, leading conversations, taking initiative, and learning how to positively influence the people around them in a more hands-on way. The idea is not just to teach leadership, but to create environments where students can actually experience it.

From what I have seen, students do not need constant reminders that they have potential. Most of them already know that on some level. What they need are more opportunities to practice becoming that version of themselves in real environments.

If your school is looking to strengthen student leadership, communication, and overall school culture in a way that lasts beyond a one-time assembly, I would love to connect and talk more about how we can support your students!

ASSEMBLIES